How I Raised $13,000 (and My Holiday Spirits) with the Power of Words

The headline hits and the headline flops

Okay, folks, gather 'round the digital fireplace and let me tell you a tale of fundraising triumph!

It all started with a goal: raise $12,000 in 10 days to give the amazing teachers at my school a little extra holiday cheer.

Now, these aren't just any teachers. These are Montessori guides, assistants, and staff (at the Montessori School Rochester, Rochester Hills, MI) who pour their hearts and souls into their work every single day and show up reliability regardless of how they feel, with huge smiles on their faces and hearts filled with love, kindness, and dedication, and they deserve a holiday season filled with joy (and maybe a spa day or two!).

I've been running this campaign for the past 4 years with decent success, but this year, I was determined to take it up a notch. I'd been working with a writing coach (fancy, I know!) and discovered the magical power of headlines. Armed with this newfound knowledge and my trusty fundraising tool, GiveButter (seriously, these guys are the best!), I set out on my quest for holiday gold.

Why Headlines? The Science of Snagging Attention

Before I dive into my headline hits and misses, let's talk about why headlines are so important. In our world of endless scrolling and information overload, a headline is your one chance to grab someone by the eyeballs and say, "Hey! Look at this!" Think of it like a first impression. You wouldn't show up to a holiday party in your pajamas, would you? (Unless it's a pajama party, then rock on!) Your headline is the outfit your campaign wears. It needs to be eye-catching, intriguing, and relevant to the occasion.

And there's science to back this up! Studies have shown that a strong headline can increase readership by as much as 500%. That's a whole lot of potential donors scrolling past if your headline falls flat.

GiveButter: My Fundraising Fairy Godmother

Now, let's talk tools. GiveButter is my all-time favorite fundraising platform, and it's not just because their support team is always ready to lend a hand (although that's a major plus!).

GiveButter is incredibly user-friendly, and their training resources are top-notch, making it a breeze to set up and manage your campaign. They even offer to review your campaigns! Talk about going above and beyond.

The Headline Hits: Spreading Holiday Cheer (and Generating Cash)

Alright, let's get to the juicy stuff: the headlines! Here are a few of my top performers that raked in over $2,000 in a single day:

• "Naughty or Nice?" This playful headline tapped into the holiday spirit and sparked curiosity. Who wouldn't want to know what those adorable kids were up to? (Spoiler alert: they were all nice!)

• "Dance Off!" This headline was paired with a video of our faculty and students busting a move to a holiday classic. It was pure joy, and the donations poured in. Imagine Mr. Henderson, our usually stern principal, doing the Jingle Bell Rock with a twinkle in his eye! The laughter was contagious, and the donations followed suit.

• "From the Bottom of Our Hearts" This heartfelt headline tugged at the heartstrings and showcased the gratitude of our students. It was a reminder of the true meaning of the season. We even included a clip of little Sarah, a shy first-grader, saying, "Thank you, teachers, for making learning fun!" It melted everyone's hearts.

Each of these headlines was accompanied by a short, engaging video. We're talking 30-50 seconds of pure holiday magic: kids singing carols, teachers rocking reindeer antlers, and everyone spreading festive cheer. The combination of a catchy headline and a captivating video proved to be a winning formula.

The Headline Flops: A Lesson in What Not to Do

Of course, not all of my headlines were winners. Here are a couple that fell flat:

• "Remembering the Magic" A bit too vague and sentimental. It didn't create a sense of urgency or excitement.

• "A Note from Our Students" While well-intentioned, this headline lacked that attention-grabbing spark.

These headlines, while perfectly fine, didn't generate the same level of engagement as the others. They taught me a valuable lesson: your headline needs to be more than just words; it needs to be an invitation to a party, a sneak peek at a surprise, a reason to click and discover more. The winning headlines used strong verbs and evoked specific emotions, while the flops were more passive and general.

The Results: Exceeding Expectations (and Spreading Holiday Joy)

So, what was the final verdict? Drumroll, please... We raised over $13,000! That's right, we exceeded our goal and then some. I attribute this success to a few key factors:

• The Power of Headlines: Those catchy, engaging headlines definitely played a starring role in attracting donors.

• Video Magic: The short, fun videos brought our campaign to life and showcased the joy we were spreading.

• GiveButter's Awesome Platform: Their user-friendly tools and amazing support made the entire process a breeze.

• Embracing the Fun: We didn't take ourselves too seriously. We sang, we danced, we laughed, and we let our personalities shine through.

• Community Support: We also spread the word through social media, local businesses, and even had a booth at the town's holiday festival. The whole community rallied behind our teachers!

Key Takeaways: Headline Hacks for Fundraising Success

Want to create headlines that convert? Here are a few tips I learned along the way:

• Keep it concise: No one wants to read a novel in your headline. Get to the point quickly.

• Use strong verbs: Action words create a sense of urgency and excitement.

• Appeal to emotions: Tug at the heartstrings, make 'em laugh, or inspire them to take action.

• Highlight the benefit: What's in it for the donor? Let them know how their contribution will make a difference.

• Test and refine: Don't be afraid to experiment with different headlines and see what works best.

More Than Just Money

This fundraising campaign was about more than just raising money. It was about bringing joy to our guides, assistants, and staff, spreading holiday cheer, and reminding ourselves of the power of community. And you know what? I think we achieved that and then some.

But the real magic was seeing the smiles on their faces and knowing that we had made a difference in their lives. It was a reminder that even small acts of kindness can have a big impact.

So, the next time you're planning a fundraising campaign, remember the power of a great headline. It's the key to unlocking generosity, spreading joy, and making a real difference in the world. Now go and fundraise like a boss!

👉 If you enjoy reading this post, feel free to share it with friends! Or feel free to click the ❤️ button on this post so more people can discover it on Substack