Invisible Strings

The things nobody tells you about cognitive biases (a story)

Photo by Shane Devlin on Unsplash

(As told by a very experienced, slightly spooky, positive psychology geek)

Psst... Come closer. I've seen a lot in my time, swirling around this old world. And let me tell you, the living are far more predictable than you might think.

It's all down to these sneaky little things called cognitive biases. They're like invisible puppet strings, tugging at our thoughts and decisions.

I'm going to tell you a story about a perfectly ordinary woman named Emily, and how she – and you – can start cutting those strings.

I. The "Found Money" Fiasco (And the "Aha!")

It all starts, as these things often do, with a little bit of "found money." Emily gets a small, unexpected bonus at work. Immediately, her brain starts buzzing.

"Treat yourself! You deserve it!" it whispers. She spots a gorgeous, overpriced handbag online—one she's been eyeing for months—and bam, it's hers. No second thoughts, no careful budgeting. Just pure, impulsive joy... followed by a pang of regret a few days later.

Sound familiar? I see you nodding. We've all been there.

Emily is a smart cookie; I'll give her that. She's got a good job, good friends, and a generally good head on her shoulders. But like all of us, she's got these hidden patterns in her thinking—these little glitches in the matrix—that can lead her astray. She doesn't realize it yet, but that handbag incident? That's just the tip of the iceberg.

That feeling of, "Wait, why did I do that?" That's the "Aha!" moment. That's the first crack in the wall of our perfectly constructed (and often flawed) realities.

Here's the truth nobody tells you: Understanding these cognitive biases is the key. It's the key to making better decisions, having stronger relationships, and navigating this crazy world with a little more clarity and a lot less regret. And it takes courage. Real courage to look inward and challenge the very way your mind works.

II. Confirmation Bias: Emily's Favorite Bistro (And the Power of Belief)

Emily loves "The Cozy Corner Bistro." She raves about it to everyone. In her mind, it's the best restaurant in town.

Now, here's where the confirmation bias creeps in. When Emily reads online reviews of The Cozy Corner, she focuses on the five-star raves. "See! I told you it was amazing!" she thinks. The occasional two-star review complaining about slow service or a bland dish? She dismisses those. "Those people probably just had a bad day," she mutters.

Even when she herself has a slightly mediocre experience (the soup is a bit cold, the waiter forgets her drink order), she bends over backward to justify it. "Well, they were really busy tonight," she tells herself. "It's usually much better."

This, is confirmation bias in action. We gravitate towards information that confirms what we already believe. We filter out anything that challenges our precious worldview. Our brains are wired this way – it's a shortcut, a way to avoid the discomfort of cognitive dissonance. Thinking, Fast and Slow by Daniel Kahneman, explores this in more detail.

But how do we break free? We actively seek out dissenting opinions. We ask ourselves, "What if I'm wrong?" We force ourselves to consider the other side, even if it feels uncomfortable. It's like flexing a muscle – the more you do it, the stronger you get.

III. The Anchoring Effect: Emily Buys a Car (And Gets Stuck on a Number)

Emily needs a new car. She walks onto the lot, and the first car she sees has a sticker price that makes her eyes widen. It's way out of her budget, but that number – that big, bold, initial price – gets lodged in her brain.

This is the anchoring effect. That first piece of information, even if it's completely arbitrary, becomes our reference point. Everything else is judged relative to that anchor.

The salesperson, a smooth operator (I've seen his type for centuries), "helpfully" points out that the car is "on sale" – a few thousand dollars knocked off the original price. Emily, still reeling from the initial sticker shock, sees this as a fantastic deal. She's so focused on the "discount" that she doesn't fully consider whether the sale price is still too high.

To combat the anchoring effect, we need to be aware of it. We need to do our own research before we encounter that first number. We need to come up with our own independent estimate of what something is worth, and then, and only then, look at the price tag. Predictably Irrational by Dan Ariely, delves into this and other biases beautifully.

IV. The Availability Heuristic: Emily's Fear of Flying (And the Power of Vivid Images)

A news report flashes across Emily's TV screen: a dramatic plane crash, with fiery wreckage and heartbreaking interviews. Emily, who has a flight booked next week, suddenly feels a knot of anxiety in her stomach.

"I knew flying was dangerous!" she thinks, her heart racing.

This is the availability heuristic. We judge the likelihood of events based on how easily examples come to mind. Vivid, emotionally charged events – like plane crashes – stick in our memory, making us overestimate their probability.

The reality, of course, is that flying is statistically far safer than driving. But statistics don't have the same emotional punch as a dramatic news story.

To overcome the availability heuristic, we need to rely on data, not just gut feelings. We need to seek out the base rates, the actual probabilities, and not let ourselves be swayed by the most readily available (and often misleading) images in our minds. The Black Swan by Nassim Nicholas Taleb addresses exactly this issue of misjudging probabilities.

V. The Bandwagon Effect: Emily's New Gadget (And the Urge to Fit In)

Everyone at Emily's office is sporting the latest "SmartWrist" – a fancy, expensive gadget that tracks your steps, monitors your sleep, and probably makes coffee too (I exaggerate, but only slightly). Emily doesn't really need one, but she feels strange pressure to conform.

"Everyone has one," she thinks. "Maybe I'm missing out."

This is the bandwagon effect. We're social creatures, and we have a deep-seated desire to belong. We often adopt behaviors and beliefs simply because other people are doing it, even if we don't have a strong personal reason.

To resist the bandwagon, we need to cultivate our own inner compass. We need to ask ourselves, "Do I really want this? Or am I just following the crowd?" It takes courage to stand apart, to be different, but it's essential for authentic living.

VI. The Halo Effect: Emily's Political Crush (And the Illusion of Perfection)

Emily watches a political debate. One candidate is particularly charismatic, delivering their speech with passion and eloquence. Emily finds herself nodding along, captivated by their presence.

"They seem so intelligent and trustworthy," she thinks, without really analyzing the substance of their policies.

This is the halo effect. One positive quality (in this case, charisma) creates a "halo" that makes us assume other positive qualities, even without evidence. We project an idealized image onto the person, product, or brand.

To avoid the halo effect, we need to be critical thinkers. We need to evaluate different qualities independently. Just because someone is a good speaker doesn't automatically mean they're a good leader. We need to look beyond the surface and dig deeper.

VII. Emily's Reflection (And Your Call to Action)

Sitting at her desk, handbag now gathering dust in the closet, Emily reflects on her week. She sees the patterns, the invisible strings that have been tugging at her decisions. She realizes that recognizing these biases is the first step. It's a continuous process, a lifelong journey of self-awareness. It takes courage to create self-awareness. And it takes just as much courage to face these cognitive biases.

I've laid out a few of the most common culprits: confirmation bias, anchoring, availability, bandwagon, and halo. There are many more lurking in the shadows of your mind.

But now you know. You're aware. And that awareness is your superpower.

So, what are you going to do about it? Will you continue to let these biases steer your life? Or will you take the reins, challenge your own thinking, and make conscious, deliberate choices?

Start small. Pick one bias that resonates with you. Practice recognizing it in your daily life. Challenge yourself to think differently. Write it down. Seek out diverse perspectives. Read, learn, and grow with courage and conviction that you have the self-awareness to recognize these invisable strings.

---

References:

• Ariely, D. (2008). Predictably irrational: The hidden forces that shape our decisions. HarperCollins.

• Kahneman, D. (2011). Thinking, fast and slow. Farrar, Straus and Giroux.

• Taleb, N. N. (2007). The black swan: The impact of the highly improbable. Random House.

---

👉 If you enjoy reading this post, feel free to share it with friends! Or feel free to click the ❤️ button on this post so more people can discover it on Substack