The crisp $500 bill crackled in my hand, a stark contrast to the worn leather of my wallet. It wasn't a small sum, especially for Sergio, my pro bono client.
I pictured him trudging through the biting December wind, his shoulders hunched against the cold, the weight of providing for his two little girls pressing down on him.
He'd arrived from Eastern Europe just nine months ago, his English halting, his life a constant struggle. One evening, I saw him shivering at the bus stop, his thin coat offering little protection from the icy rain.
He noticed me, a flicker of embarrassment in his eyes, and quickly averted his gaze. It was then that I decided to help.
I'd told him about the giving tree at my work—a chance to ask for a little help this Christmas. He could write down his wishes and his girls' wishes, and we'd make them happen. But he didn't. Pride, perhaps, or maybe the ingrained reluctance to ask for help that I knew all too well. So, I did it for him.
Yesterday, when I handed him the envelope, his eyes widened in disbelief. He didn't want to take it. "Please, Doc," I insisted, using the nickname he'd given me during our coaching sessions, "It's for the girls."
When he finally, reluctantly, agreed, he looked at me with a question burning in his eyes. "Doc," he began, his voice thick with emotion, "what strings are attached to this money?"
His question echoed in my mind long after our meeting ended. It was a question born from experience, from a life lived in a world where scarcity was the dominating emotion and where gifts, if they came at all, always had a cost. It was a question that transported me back to my own childhood.
The Ghost of Christmas Past
I grew up in a communist country. Christmas was a time of want, not abundance. The shelves were bare; the lines for the meager offerings stretched for blocks. I remember standing with my mother in the bitter cold, our breath clouding the air, hoping to get a few potatoes and maybe, if we were lucky, a single orange. Even the few gifts we managed to find were often tinged with the bitter taste of obligation and the unspoken expectation of reciprocity.
In a collectivist culture, the individual is subservient to the group. The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few. Asking for help is seen as a weakness, a burden on the collective. Receiving a gift without strings attached is almost unthinkable. There's always a debt to be repaid, a favor to be returned. This mindset is deeply ingrained in those of us who grew up in such societies. It's a survival mechanism, a way to navigate a world where resources are scarce and trust is a luxury. But it also leaves us with a deep-seated fear of indebtedness, a reluctance to accept help even when it's offered freely.
This "scarcity mindset" can have a profound impact on our behavior, making us more risk-averse, more likely to hoard resources, and less likely to trust others. I remember how my own parents, despite their love for me, hesitated to accept any help from neighbors, fearing they would be forever in their debt.
The Gift of Trust
When Sergio asked me what strings were attached to the money, he was expressing a fear that's all too common among immigrants from collectivist cultures. He was afraid that my generosity came with a hidden cost and that I expected something in return.
My response was simple: "There are no strings attached, Sergio. This is a gift, freely given. I want you and your girls to have a good Christmas."
The look of relief on his face was worth more than any gift I could have given him. In that moment, I realized that the greatest gift I could offer him wasn't money but trust. Trust that I wasn't trying to manipulate him, that I genuinely wanted to help. I saw a glimmer of hope spark in his eyes, a flicker of belief that maybe, just maybe, this new world could be different.
Breaking the Chains of Scarcity
For those of us who grew up in collectivist cultures, learning to ask for help and receive gifts without fear can be a lifelong journey. It requires us to challenge our deeply ingrained beliefs about scarcity and reciprocity. It requires us to learn to trust others and to believe that their generosity is genuine. It's a journey I'm still on myself, learning to let go of the fear that kindness always comes with a price.
But it's a journey worth taking. Because when we can break free from the chains of scarcity, we open ourselves up to a world of abundance. We learn that we're not alone and that there are people who care about us and want to help us succeed. And we discover that the greatest gifts are often the ones that come with no strings attached.
The Effect of Generosity
The act of giving and receiving gifts is a powerful one. It can create bonds of connection and strengthen relationships. It can inspire gratitude and generosity in others. And it can help to break down the barriers of scarcity and fear that so often divide us.
When we give freely, without expectation of reward, we create a ripple effect of generosity that can spread far and wide. Perhaps Sergio, having experienced this unexpected kindness, will one day be in a position to pay it forward. Maybe he'll see someone struggling, remember the warmth of a stranger's generosity, and offer a helping hand without any expectation of return.
This Christmas, let us all strive to give and receive gifts with open hearts and open minds. Let us remember that the true value of a gift lies not in its monetary worth, but in the spirit of generosity and love with which it is given. And let us all work to create a world where scarcity is replaced by abundance, and fear is replaced by trust, one genuine act of kindness at a time.
👉 If you enjoy reading this post, feel free to share it with friends! Or feel free to click the ❤️ button on this post so more people can discover it on Substack
What a lovely story Madalena. Kindness is never forgotten.
Happy Holidays!