Why Our Brains Treat Creative Courage Like a Threat

Risk. Survive. Rewire.

Photo by Teslariu Mihai on Unsplash

It happens every time.

Cursor blinking. Hands sweating. My body staging a full-blown hostage situation over a 700-word blog post.

I can hear my heart in my ears. My vision tunnels. Somewhere deep inside, my brain is screaming like the house is on fire.

But nothing is on fire.

I am in my kitchen. The dishes on the counter. The fridge hums the same low tune it always does.

I am safe.

So why does hitting publish feel like I am about to be burned at the stake?

The Ancient Alarm That Won’t Shut Up

Here is what I wish someone had told me years ago: Your nervous system does not care about your dreams. It cares about keeping you breathing. Learn to publish while it panics.

It does not care about your book deal or your Substack subscriber count. To that ancient wiring in your brainstem, the kind passed down from ancestors who slept with one eye open, visibility equals risk.

Neuroscience has a name for this: amygdala hijack. Your fear center storms the control room, cuts the power, and locks the rational part of your brain in a closet. Suddenly you are not a grown adult with bills and a Costco membership. You are a cave dweller about to be eaten alive.

Because thousands of years ago, standing out got you killed. Rejected by the tribe meant exiled. Alone meant death.

Today it is just an audience. A comment section. A handful of internet strangers.

But your amygdala cannot tell the difference. To your nervous system, rejection still smells like death.

The Week I Couldn’t Hit Publish

The first time I tried to share something raw, my body went to war with me.

It was about the week my son was in the hospital. About pretending I was fine while beeping monitors kept score in the background. About the texture of fear that lives in pediatric waiting rooms at three in the morning.

I wrote it in one sitting. Ugly-cried through the last three paragraphs. Then stared at the draft for six days.

My finger hovered over the publish button so long the screen went dark.

I told myself it was too personal. Too messy. Not “on brand.” The truth was simpler. I was terrified that the world would read it and silently vote me off the island.

On the seventh day, I published it at eleven p.m., late enough that I could pretend nobody would see it. Then I closed my laptop and dry-heaved into the kitchen sink.

What Happened Next

I braced for judgment. Or worse, silence.

Instead, my inbox filled with me too.

Parents who had slept in hospital chairs. Professionals with shiny careers and hollow insides. Strangers who needed someone to say the thing they did not know how to say.

One message came from a father whose daughter had been in the NICU for three months. He wrote, “I have been pretending I am fine for so long that I forgot it was a performance. Thank you for the permission to stop.”

I sat in my kitchen, same counter, same dishes, and felt something shift. Not relief exactly. More like recognition.

The thing I thought would exile me had stitched us back together.

The Rewiring Begins

You would think it gets easier. It does not.

Three weeks later, I wrote about the gap between the parent I thought I would be and the one spilling cereal and losing my temper. My hands shook worse than the first time because now I knew what I was risking. That first post had built something fragile. This one could snap it.

I published anyway. Not because I felt brave, but because I remembered that father’s message.

By the third vulnerable post, my body still protested on schedule. The sweating, the tunnel vision, the pounding heart. But the fear had lost its authority. I could feel my amygdala pulling the fire alarm, but I did not evacuate the building. I just nodded at it. Yes, I know, you think I am going to die. Then I hit publish anyway.

Neuroscientists call this fear extinction learning. Every time you do the thing your body swears will kill you, and nothing bad happens, you lay a new track in the brain.

Risk. Survive. Rewire.

The pathway from “vulnerability” to “danger” starts to weaken. A new pathway forms: “vulnerability” to “connection.” Your amygdala does not stop ringing the alarm. It just starts ringing softer.

The Bridge Between Fear and Freedom

Something profound happens in the space between panic and publish.

At first, it feels like betrayal, as if you are turning against your own biology. But what you are really doing is teaching your nervous system that safety has evolved. The tribe you once feared losing still exists. It just looks different now: community, readers, listeners, strangers who find themselves in your words. The same visibility that once felt fatal becomes the thing that keeps you alive.

This is where courage begins to rewire the brain.

What Nobody Tells You About Courage

Courage is not about waiting until you feel ready.

It is not about conquering fear or transcending your biology or finally becoming the person who does not shake before hitting send.

Courage is simpler and harder than that. It is doing it while shaking.

It is knowing the alarm will go off and publishing anyway. Not because you are fearless, but because you have collected enough evidence that your nervous system is wrong.

The dishes will still be on the counter. The fridge will still hum. You will still be safe.

And somewhere, someone you will never meet will read what you wrote and finally exhale. They will think: Oh. Me too.

The Math Your Amygdala Cannot Do

Here is what I know now, after fifty published posts and fifty small deaths: The fear shows up every single time. Same script. Same empty threats. Same biological theater.

But the me too messages never stop coming.

The mother who finally told her family she was struggling. The artist who shared his work after ten years of hiding it. The entrepreneur who admitted his business almost failed. All of them said some version of the same thing: Your honesty gave me permission.

That is the math your amygdala cannot do.

It cannot calculate the weight of one person feeling less alone. It cannot measure the value of truth told in a world optimized for performance. It cannot add up all the invisible connections that form when someone finally stops pretending.

Your nervous system is still doing the math from ten thousand years ago, when the tribe was everything and exile meant death.

But we are not in that world anymore.

The Real Threat

The danger was never rejection.

The danger was the life unlived because fear said “not yet.” The story you never told because you were waiting to feel fearless. The connection you never made because your amygdala convinced you that safety meant silence.

Every time I hover over that publish button, still sweating, still hearing my heartbeat, I think about that father in the NICU. About the permission he did not know he needed until someone else went first.

And I remember: courage is not the absence of fear. It is the presence of something worth being afraid for.

So I hit publish.

The cat stays asleep. The world does not end.

And somewhere, someone whispers: me too.

That is how we find each other. That is how we survive. That is how the tribe welcomes us home.

---

PS: My writing is powered by coffee in the morning and tea in the afternoon. To keep the words flowing, consider contributing to my caffeine fund.

👉 If you enjoy reading this post, feel free to share it with friends! Or feel free to click the ❤️ button on this post so more people can discover it on Substack.